shreyalogy.com

(Literary. Obviously. My lawyer — me — insists.)

There is a very specific type of person in this world.

You know them. You have met them at family dinners, in office corridors, in comment sections, in the DMs of strangers on the internet who found your post about buying a new bag and felt compelled to tell you about debt.

This person has not been asked for their opinion.

This person will give it anyway.

A Brief Taxonomy of Unsolicited Advice Givers

Before we proceed, I want to establish that there are several species here, and they must not be confused with each other. Lumping them together is intellectually lazy and also inaccurate.

The Concerned Elder

This one loves you. This is important to remember, because it is the only thing stopping this from being a crime. They give advice because they genuinely believe that their life experience — which took place in entirely different economic, social, and historical conditions — is directly applicable to yours.

They will tell you to save money while simultaneously telling you to get married, which costs money, but we don’t point this out because we are civilised.

The LinkedIn Commentator

You post something personal. Maybe a small win. Maybe a reflection. Maybe you just said you were having a hard week.

The LinkedIn Commentator appears.

They write four paragraphs. They use the phrase “in my experience.” They have reframed your lived moment as a learning opportunity. They end with a call to action.

You did not ask for a call to action.

The Unsolicited Diet Advisor

You ate something.

They saw.

That’s all it took.

They are now explaining macros to you like you are a golden retriever who wandered into a nutrition seminar.

They have concerns.

About your choices.

Which you made.

For yourself.

With your own body.

The Relationship Expert Who Has Never Met Your Partner

Based on one thing you said in passing, they have diagnosed your entire relationship, assessed the long-term compatibility, and drafted an exit strategy.

All without being asked.

All with total confidence.

The Career Counsellor

You mentioned your job. Or your career path. Or the fact that you exist and have ambitions.

They now want to know why you’re not doing something else.

Something better.

Something more stable.

Something their cousin’s husband does that apparently has tremendous growth potential.

Why Does This Keep Happening?

Here is what I’ve figured out, and I say this with the confidence of someone who has spent an unreasonable amount of time thinking about why people do things:

Unsolicited advice is almost never about you.

It’s about the advisor.

When someone sees your life and immediately starts suggesting improvements, what they’re actually doing is processing their own anxiety. About their choices. About the roads they didn’t take. About the fact that you seem to be doing something differently from them and that creates a small but persistent discomfort, like a pebble in a shoe.

The advice is the pebble leaving.

It’s not malicious, mostly.

It’s not even particularly thoughtful.

It’s a reflex.

A “I saw a gap, I filled it” impulse dressed up as generosity.

The problem is that you have to receive it.

The Special Category: Advice Given to Women

I want to stay here for a moment, because there is a specific kind of unsolicited advice that is reserved almost exclusively for women, and I think it deserves its own exhibit in this museum of other people’s nerve.

Women get told — constantly, cheerfully, without pause — what to do with their:

• Bodies
• Relationships
• Career timelines
• Fertility windows
• Ambitions (too much of them)
• Humility (not enough of it)
• Tone
• Appearance
• Life choices, in general, as a category

And the most fascinating part?

The advice is always contradictory.

Be ambitious, but not too ambitious, because then you seem aggressive.

Be confident, but not too confident, because then you seem arrogant.

Want a career, but also want a family, and if you want both, manage the logistics of that quietly and without complaint.

The goalposts don’t just move.

They are on wheels.

They are being actively pushed by someone who will also tell you to smile more.

How to Actually Handle It

I have tried many approaches over the years.

Some more successful than others.

The Gracious Deflect

“Thank you, I’ll think about it.”

You will not think about it.

But saying so ends the conversation and preserves the relationship.

Useful for the Concerned Elder, who means well.

The Redirect

Ask them something about themselves immediately.

People who love giving advice also, as a rule, love talking about themselves.

One question and you’re free.

This is manipulation, but it’s the victimless kind.

The Honest Response

“I didn’t ask, but thank you.”

Brave.

Occasionally worth it.

Only recommended if you are willing to have a whole conversation about why you said that, because you will.

The Chaos Option

Agree enthusiastically with everything.

Add increasingly absurd details.

Watch them become uncertain.

This works best on LinkedIn Commentators and Career Counsellors who have lost the thread of reality.

The Internal Monologue Approach

This is my personal favourite.

You say nothing.

You nod.

You maintain eye contact.

And inside your head, you are writing the most spectacular fictional response, the kind that ends with a slow walk away and a perfect parting line.

You don’t say any of it out loud.

But you have it.

And it’s yours.

(This is what I mean by crimes — literary. Completely contained. Entirely satisfying.)

The Real Point

Here’s the thing I actually want to say, underneath all of this:

Your life is not a problem that other people need to solve.

It’s not a rough draft waiting for their edits.

It’s not a pitch deck that needs their notes.

It’s yours — complicated and ongoing and full of context they don’t have and probably never will.

The people who have figured out the most about how to live are, without exception, deeply uninterested in telling other people how to live.

Because they know how much they don’t know.

Because they understand that the view from inside someone else’s life is nothing like the view from outside it.

The loudest advisors are almost always the most uncertain ones.

So the next time someone volunteers their wisdom in your direction — uninvited, unseasoned, completely free of charge —

Nod.

Smile.

And remember that you are the writer, director, and producer of your own story.

They’re just someone who wandered onto the set.

---

Welcome to Shreyalogy. Where we support quiet rebellion, strongly worded internal monologues, and the legal right to be completely unbothered.